Misleading information regarding Rogue damage

[Guest]

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever

Login with username, password and session length

Getting Started

Rules

Character Mover

Optimization Guide

EZ Wiki

EZ Guide

Magelo

Zone List

Spell Recipes

T10.5 Spell Recipes

Crafting Recipes

Donate

EZ Player Discord

[EZ Server Files]

EZ Server Files

EZ Client Downloads

Custom UF MiniMap

Custom UF Inventory

EQEmu Server Status

EQEmulator Home

Allakhazam Home

UFMissingFilesList

TwitchTV

[Sarthin]

Ok, so we talked about classes DPS yesterday in /ooc and some of the information I talked about was not correct, as we have figured out today after some tests.

As some of you know, I am currently working on DPS parses for melee classes on Test Server. I should be done soon and will post the information gathered as soon as possible.

When it comes to the melee DPS I found Zerks, Rogues and Monks to be pretty close matched in terms of DPS. All three classes were around the 20-21 million sustainable dps

Then I received information about Rogues doing insane backstabs and decided to look further into it. Together with Draca we found out that the Rogue's damage is different on the Test Server, where I did my parses, compared to EZ Live Server. Backstabs do way less damage on Test Server compared to on EZ Live.

So you can forget what I said last night about Rogue's DPS. It's not around 20 million damage on Live server at all. It's actually 65 million! damage on EZ live, using best setup with SPD in mainhand and Cratos with dual NS12's in off hand. This equals the damage of 3 monks!!

So you can see how balanced this is 

[Loyal]

what am I missing that The SPD is better than the Ultimate Dagger XII?

[Sarthin]

what am I missing that The SPD is better than the Ultimate Dagger XII?

Correct. Not just better, but more or less 3 x better.

I tested the EZ Live Rogue with SPD in main hand and Cratos with 2x NS12 in off hand and did 65 million DPS.

Using UW12 dagger in main hand and Cratos in off hand goes for 20 million DPS.

So basically the SPD gives a Rogue 3x the normal damage.

I don't mean to play the devil's advocate here, but I think we can all agree that this is unbalanced as hell compared to the other DPS classes, no matter how much we love our cloaks and daggers

[Loyal]

I get that its doing more damage, but why? Aren't all the stats for the UDXII better than SPD?

Almost seems like something is broken with the SPD if we cant point at a reason for it being so much more damage.

[Sarthin]

I get that its doing more damage, but why? Aren't all the stats for the UDXII better than SPD?

Almost seems like something is broken with the SPD if we cant point at a reason for it being so much more damage.

Draca can explain this much better than me.

[Draca]

Draca can explain this much better than me.

The issue with the UW Dagger is the backstab damage bonus is over cap, and results in either no backstab bonus, or very little. Ultimately no DPS class is supposed to be out-DPSing another by 3x, so following some upcoming changes, some tuning may be necessary for Rogues.

-Draca

[wachna]

Hm? I thought you wanted to adjust UW dmg so it is same level as SPD?

[Loyal]

Well this is some very interesting stuff!

A little bonkers what you can find when you spend a little time on each class to see what they may actually be capable of if you were to devote as much time and attention to them as if they were your main character!

[Ginge]

Another thing that's been known about for ages, it's all in the broken repair shop threads so we don't end up with umpteen different threads about broken stuff.

Post anything broken in there no need for individual posts for each broken thing.

Tank

 

[Draca]

Hm? I thought you wanted to adjust UW dmg so it is same level as SPD?

That was in the absence of specific DPS figures, and the fact the the UW damage wasn't lower on purpose, it just had an over capped stat that was bugging out it's damage, which is honestly all I paid attention to at the time. There's no particular reason Rogues should be 3x the DPS of any other class, I wouldn't mind slightly superior in single target situations, losing to Berserkers in AE situations, but 65m DPS vs 16-20m for other melee DPS classes is out of whack. More to come on this in the coming weeks.

[wachna]

Ah ok I understand and yeah, rogues should not do 3 times the dmg of a monk. As long as I can use my hw uw or uw12 on my rogue and actually do dmg I am happy ;-)

It sucks to habe uw and cratos waiting for action and use SPD and RE instead

[Poker-ecaf]

why we didnt add some Discs items like Orbs from T3-T4 to add some dmg on other favor classes like Monk Zerker Ranger and no clue !!! that choose can catch lightly up on ROgue dmg ?

[Otto]

I feel this is the wrong way to go about a "fix"

Rogue damage finally feels as though the class is present. Why nerf one class that FINALLY feels usable, but rather increase the others to follow suit?

Add some fun ways to increase others, give monk full-time innerflame, berserker full-time bla bla bla - you get where I'm going.

Nerfs at this point in the game feels very counter-productive to all the work done to push things forward

Alternatively, how about a global stat squash? We have Wizard damage that unintentionally heals the target due to exceeding the damage cap. A squish could help reset this back to more manageable levels.

[Draca]

EDIT: Otto, I didn't intend to blast all your points, I just know that there are others who feel the same way, so I wanted to go point by point through your post.

Rogue damage finally feels as though the class is present. Why nerf one class that FINALLY feels usable, but rather increase the others to follow suit?

What about them being 3x the damage of any other DPS class, makes them feel usable? It's not a characteristic of rogues from any point in the game.

Add some fun ways to increase others, give monk full-time innerflame, berserker full-time bla bla bla - you get where I'm going.

Same point as above, what about them doing more damage will inherently make them more exciting to play? Content makes stuff exciting to play, you could be hitting for 12 damage in the basement of Befallen and be having an absolute blast. While EZ certainly deals in large numbers, imbalances can't be simply ignored.

Nerfs at this point in the game feels very counter-productive to all the work done to push things forward

I don't disagree, that nerfs feel pretty crappy from a player perspective, I know, I was one not that long ago. While saying that, I can't simply leave something clearly imbalanced just because people like seeing obscene backstabs, which can account for over 1/3 of the maximum number of hitpoints we can use.

Alternatively, how about a global stat squash? We have Wizard damage that unintentionally heals the target due to exceeding the damage cap. A squish could help reset this back to more manageable levels.

At this point, because of the sheer amount of interconnected things, a stat squish isn't something we can reasonably expect to happen any time soon. While it seems like you could do a blanket "reduce everything by XX%" and it should be balanced, that's not the case in practice. Even if something like that worked in a general sense, the amount of manual adjustments to balance the outliers would be incredibly high.



Ultimately my goal is to balance some of the classes who are clearly less desirable, and give people a choice in who they choose to use to tank, to DPS and heal. While warriors should be the best pure tank, they shouldn't be the only choice. Nor should rogues be the only good option for DPS because they outpace every other DPS class by three times. If someone wanted to run a SK, Cleric, Bst, Mnk, Wiz, Dru group, than I want them to be to be able to do so. It might take more work than self-healing warriors tank for auto-attacking melee classes, and paladins proc'ing monster heals to get through content, but I know some people want more than that, and want more involvement in the survival of their groups. I know that everyone is waiting for less talk, more action, but I can assure you, beyond VP there is a lot of exciting stuff coming up.

-Draca

[Otto]

I mostly agree with your responses, Draca - And this certainly isn't intended to say you are wrong, or doing something wrong, but rather observations and personal opinion. I feel this is important for me to state.

What I probably failed to express is that I personally (opinion) feel that we finally have a class that stands out from the pack. This is absolutely due to the dramatic difference in performance, which is the issue here.

Class and role identity is pretty washed out, but that's sorta the EZ that has existed since 2011 or 2012. (Back when T1 and T2 were Anguish, folks really just 1 or 2 boxed here)

Here's another curious component to why rogues being huge damage dealers is significant - Because it finally places them in the "Has a use other than hide/sneak and group CotH"

Classes we need in order to progress
Warrior
Paladin

Classes we don't need, but sorta do cool stuff
Necromancer (Good AoE, cool to see Death proc)
Rogue (Single target damage)
Berserker (AoE i guess. This is less relevant in the end-game.)

Classes we don't need at all, but might have a gimmick we convince ourselves we need
Shaman (Grudge)
Bard (Group DA. Can replace this need with donation items)

Classes that suck, and get dragged around so we can give them loot
Ranger
Monk (Does OK damage, but whatever. I love monks, don't hate me)
Enchanter
Cleric
Druid
Mage
Wizard
Beastlord
Shadowknight

---------------------

So what am I trying to say here?... Basically, as stated above, it would be most excellent if there was some balance. I don't have all the answers, and won't pretend to have a fix-all remedy, but most of us would love to have a tough time deciding on what to use in a 6-man group.

Looking above, it's obvious what I would NOT pick, and it's obvious now why some folks 6-man group is War / War / Rog / Rog / Rog / Pal

Maybe nerfs are the way, but puts us back into the same position as before where everyone runs War / Pal - and just drags the rest along to loot items.

Ok I'm done for now, so I can stop rambling on.... lol

Advanced search

• Recent & Upcoming Changes by Dokplayer2 [April 23, 2024, 10:48:30 pm]
• Issue with my epic by fangzy [April 22, 2024, 07:32:32 pm]
• Official Guild Creation R... by Sarthin [April 21, 2024, 03:37:37 pm]
• Few Changes - T11, VP, Gu... by clbreastmilk [April 10, 2024, 11:32:33 am]
• Fear Itself, the new Even... by Mixlor [April 08, 2024, 12:21:45 am]
• Combine HoH tokens macro.... by Dbeast [April 04, 2024, 05:10:46 pm]
• Warlock self buffs by Fecs [April 04, 2024, 03:56:08 pm]
• T11 Feedback Thread by Pubis [April 03, 2024, 12:54:53 pm]
• T10 Sunderock quest track... by Marcone [March 12, 2024, 07:12:11 am]
• It makes me very happy to... by Sarthin [March 10, 2024, 08:18:12 am]
• Broken Stuff Repair Shop ... by gnonim [March 08, 2024, 10:39:39 am]
• World loot currently brok... by Sarthin [March 08, 2024, 12:36:31 am]
• Testing Help Needed - Tes... by Sarthin [February 28, 2024, 09:49:51 am]
• Tier 11 - Kael Drakkel by Sarthin [February 25, 2024, 09:11:15 am]
• Set filters macro by Marcone [February 23, 2024, 05:13:59 pm]
• TOFS and possible spell b... by AreFitz [February 20, 2024, 02:31:05 pm]
• At Long Last....Tier 11. by Draca [February 16, 2024, 09:30:46 pm]
• Kickoff to T11 by Draca [February 15, 2024, 08:45:03 pm]
• T11 NPC Testers by Serra Angel [February 05, 2024, 05:20:29 pm]
• RALLOS ZEK EVENT by gnonim [February 01, 2024, 09:13:31 am]
• EZ Update - T11, Recent C... by Draca [January 31, 2024, 05:25:11 pm]
• T5 Named kills by ZerarWarrior [January 24, 2024, 08:08:07 am]
• Possible bug by Raygan [January 17, 2024, 03:35:08 pm]
• Tier 11, Kael Drakkel Upd... by Draca [January 09, 2024, 12:42:02 pm]
• Multi-botting instances by Serra Angel [December 31, 2023, 02:19:16 am]
• New Characters crashing w... by ZerarWarrior [December 30, 2023, 01:16:50 pm]
• Christmas event by Dbeast [December 26, 2023, 05:08:45 pm]
• Christmas Events? by Sarthin [December 22, 2023, 10:11:20 am]
• EQ3 by orkiho [December 19, 2023, 06:02:00 pm]
• T10 Factions by Otto [December 16, 2023, 03:00:09 pm]
• eq emulator site by akpainter [December 12, 2023, 05:39:13 pm]
• T11 Status by Pubis [December 12, 2023, 05:00:10 pm]

Members

• Total Members: 6124
• Latest: Havicck

Stats

• Total Posts: 64987
• Total Topics: 5053
• Online Today: 91
• Online Ever: 8678
• (December 19, 2022, 02:32:09 pm)

Users Online

Users: 1
Guests: 63
Total: 64

skinnytick