[POLL] Tank Stonewalls

[Guest]

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever

Login with username, password and session length

Getting Started

Rules

Character Mover

Optimization Guide

EZ Wiki

EZ Guide

Magelo

Zone List

Spell Recipes

T10.5 Spell Recipes

Crafting Recipes

Donate

EZ Player Discord

[EZ Server Files]

EZ Server Files

EZ Client Downloads

Custom UF MiniMap

Custom UF Inventory

EQEmu Server Status

EQEmulator Home

Allakhazam Home

UFMissingFilesList

TwitchTV

[hateborne]

If you want, I will be able to later tonight. This isn't actually thread related, but it might be useful in the way of future abilities/clickies.

>_>
<_<

-Hate

[Camric]

Something to keep in mind regarding knights.  Once a paladin or SK is beyond the one round scenario, the chance of dieing while tanking is between slim and none.  The ability to heal must be factored into any mitigation comparisons, imo.

[Xiggie | Stone]

Incidentally, my monk occasionally steals agro from my warrior and on a normal basis sits right behind him on the agro. In T6 on boss 5 I used to have to turn my attack off on my warrior occasionally. As soon as I turn it off, within just a few seconds my monk has agro. I don't believe my pally would be able to keep agro off of my monk unless I use the scepter clicky. If my warrior dies one of my monks gets agro and I have to spam the scepter over and over to take it with my pally. This is using 2 4's and 1 5.

[Aggressive]

If Paladin and SKs want to be main tanks so badly, we need to take away their dps. Plain and Simple.

[hateborne]

Slightly off-topic, but not really.

Are people deleting their votes? We had 40, now 39.

Can anyone else confirm?


-Hate

[Brokyn]

Let me be clear... SKs in general did not ask to be main tanks.  One of them is starting a thread based on their own ideas and asking for input.

As for my input...  SK and Pally are perfectly aligned with Warriors in tanking ability as it stands now.  I believe that a wholesale drop in mitigation needs to happen across the board, to allow for lower mob dps in the future to make non-tanks a tad safer.  The only way it works is for the reduction to scale for all classes though.  It's a major overhaul, and definitely not something to be taken on while there are so many other changes in the works.

[hateborne]

Let me be clear... SKs in general did not ask to be main tanks.  One of them is starting a thread based on their own ideas and asking for input.

As for my input...  SK and Pally are perfectly aligned with Warriors in tanking ability as it stands now.  I believe that a wholesale drop in mitigation needs to happen across the board, to allow for lower mob dps in the future to make non-tanks a tad safer.  The only way it works is for the reduction to scale for all classes though.  It's a major overhaul, and definitely not something to be taken on while there are so many other changes in the works.

<3

Even if the majority said differently, this wasn't something for anytime soon. T7 soon and still feeling the effects of a source update that wholly revamped our loot system. Something this major requires across the board adjustments (mob damage, buffs numbers, etc etc). It would ALL have to be done at once or not at all.

Thank you Brokyn and thank those that have placed constructive input or criticism. This is why I started this cesspit instead of just writing up the changes, tossing to Hunter, then hoping for the best. These are too far reaching for me alone to make. The poll has ~5 days left. Although I feel the bulk of the intelligent input has already been placed (along with some less useful, more 'attack-like' input).

-Hate

[Chunka]

And if there is to be a lessening across the board for mitigation and mob DPS, at what tiers will we see this reduction? Because honestly I dont think we should see any reduction earlier than T4....so would it be from the epic clicky that stonewall is reduced? Or would you reduce it on the other clickies (SOA, pets, etc) that it may be done across the board?

I'd rather not see the epic and dropped spell stonewalls dropped in strength. If anything, then the shield (mitigation boost plus shield block and all the extra hps ends up quite powerful) and the Halloween pets. I think dropping the core stonewall would make things quite rough for newer players advancing....and would especially make it harder to obtain the SOA.

[Venia]

Decided to vote and voted to leave things as they are..... one of my rules is : if it's not broken, dont fix it

[Natedog]

allow for lower mob dps in the future to make non-tanks a tad safer.

No -- I don't want to feel safe at all in a new zone

[hateborne]

Decided to vote and voted to leave things as they are..... one of my rules is : if it's not broken, dont fix it

Heh I shudder to think what might happen when you refuse to vaccinate your children because they aren't sick and refuse to fix your brakes until your car refuses to stop.

Despite the fact that the majority voted to leave it, the poll will still stay open because I'm still interested to see how things turn out. Due to this 'colorful' discussion, I've found a few interesting things. First, I have quite a few ideas for new clickies. Second, I have also broadened my understanding of tanking as a whole. Third, I learned more about a few people. :-P

Not all was lost from this. :-)

-Hate

[Xiggie | Stone]

Third, I learned more about a few people.

As did we.

[Natedog]

This seemed oddly appropriate.


But seriously T6 is just fine with Knight tanks lol  (and I'm sure knights will be fine in T7+)

[Chunka]

Whats it matter? We're all gonna be dead Friday anyway

[Griz]

allow for lower mob dps in the future to make non-tanks a tad safer.

No -- I don't want to feel safe at all in a new zone

Overall dps is fine, I'd like to see stuff hit for less damage but faster/more accurately so I don't spend the first 70% of a fight at either 100% or 20% hp, and then randomly die.

Advanced search

• Official Guild Creation R... by Draca [June 19, 2024, 07:25:31 am]
• New Server update causing... by Mixlor [June 02, 2024, 01:01:54 am]
• Memorial Day Event by wachna [May 30, 2024, 01:52:28 pm]
• EZServer Rules by Sarthin [May 30, 2024, 01:10:12 pm]
• Fear Itself, testing week... by torotornot [May 24, 2024, 09:29:42 am]
• Fear Itself, the new Even... by kendiian [April 26, 2024, 11:48:38 pm]
• Recent & Upcoming Changes by Dokplayer2 [April 23, 2024, 10:48:30 pm]
• Issue with my epic by fangzy [April 22, 2024, 07:32:32 pm]
• Few Changes - T11, VP, Gu... by clbreastmilk [April 10, 2024, 11:32:33 am]
• Combine HoH tokens macro.... by Dbeast [April 04, 2024, 05:10:46 pm]
• Warlock self buffs by Fecs [April 04, 2024, 03:56:08 pm]
• T11 Feedback Thread by Pubis [April 03, 2024, 12:54:53 pm]
• T10 Sunderock quest track... by Marcone [March 12, 2024, 07:12:11 am]
• It makes me very happy to... by Sarthin [March 10, 2024, 08:18:12 am]
• Broken Stuff Repair Shop ... by gnonim [March 08, 2024, 10:39:39 am]
• World loot currently brok... by Sarthin [March 08, 2024, 12:36:31 am]
• Testing Help Needed - Tes... by Sarthin [February 28, 2024, 09:49:51 am]
• Tier 11 - Kael Drakkel by Sarthin [February 25, 2024, 09:11:15 am]
• Set filters macro by Marcone [February 23, 2024, 05:13:59 pm]
• TOFS and possible spell b... by AreFitz [February 20, 2024, 02:31:05 pm]
• At Long Last....Tier 11. by Draca [February 16, 2024, 09:30:46 pm]
• Kickoff to T11 by Draca [February 15, 2024, 08:45:03 pm]
• T11 NPC Testers by Serra Angel [February 05, 2024, 05:20:29 pm]
• RALLOS ZEK EVENT by gnonim [February 01, 2024, 09:13:31 am]
• EZ Update - T11, Recent C... by Draca [January 31, 2024, 05:25:11 pm]
• T5 Named kills by ZerarWarrior [January 24, 2024, 08:08:07 am]
• Possible bug by Raygan [January 17, 2024, 03:35:08 pm]
• Tier 11, Kael Drakkel Upd... by Draca [January 09, 2024, 12:42:02 pm]
• Multi-botting instances by Serra Angel [December 31, 2023, 02:19:16 am]
• New Characters crashing w... by ZerarWarrior [December 30, 2023, 01:16:50 pm]

Members

• Total Members: 6133
• Latest: entrey73

Stats

• Total Posts: 65023
• Total Topics: 5057
• Online Today: 86
• Online Ever: 8678
• (December 19, 2022, 02:32:09 pm)

Users Online

Users: 1
Guests: 95
Total: 96

skinnytick